Why is the gettier problem a problem?

The Gettier problem, in the field of epistemology, is a landmark philosophical problem concerning the understanding of descriptive knowledge. Thus, Gettier claims to have shown that the JTB account is inadequate because it does not account for all of the necessary and sufficient conditions for knowledge.

What does the Gettier problem say about knowledge?

A Gettier problem is any example that demonstrates that an individual can satisfy the classical analysis of knowledge – justified true belief – without possessing knowledge.

What is the Gettier problem quizlet?

The Gettier Problem. Gettier is arguing that while Justification, Truth, and Belief may all be necessary for knowledge, they are not jointly sufficient.

How do you make a gettier case?

1. One way to understand Gettier cases involves knowing how to make them.
2. Step 1: select any false proposition, P, for which some believer A has ample justification.
3. Step 2: generalize away from P using a principle of deductive logic to a claim Q that is true but not for the reasons adduced by A in support of P.

Is Infallibilism a good definition of knowledge?

Infallibilism. Infallibilism argues that for a belief to count as knowledge, it must be true and justified in such a way as to make it certain. So, even though Smith has good reasons for his beliefs in the Gettier case, they’re not good enough to provide certainty.

Who has knowledge in a Gettier problem?

In any Gettier Problem, the receiver of the true information has knowledge in the colloquial sense but does not have an understanding of their knowledge.

Is the Gettier challenge still relevant today?

There is no consensus, however, that any one of the attempts to solve the Gettier challenge has succeeded in fully defining what it is to have knowledge of a truth or fact. So, the force of that challenge continues to be felt in various ways, and to various extents, within epistemology.

Is there an agreement on the Gettier problem?

This is especially so, given that there has been no general agreement on how to solve the challenge posed by Gettier cases as a group — Gettier’s own ones or those that other epistemologists have observed or imagined. (Note that sometimes this general challenge is called the Gettier problem.) What, then, is the nature of knowledge?

What are the generic features of Gettier cases?

The following two generic features also help to constitute Gettier cases: 1 Fallibility. The justification that is present within each case is fallible. Although it provides good support for the… 2 Luck. What is most distinctive of Gettier cases is the luck they contain. Within any Gettier case, in fact the… More